How and when Abba Kyari can be lawfully extradited to America to face trial, By Ade Babalola, SAN 

TNT Newsline August 12, 2021 38

Abba Kyari

Last week, I commenced a discussion on the statutory regime of extradition in Nigeria, with the case of the suspended DCP Abba Kyari in perspective.
As already discussed, extradition of a fugitive criminal is premised on either international comity or by the provision of an existing treaty between nations, and in Nigeria, all extradition proceedings must be negotiated through the office of the Attorney General of the Federation.
It must be emphasised that for the purposes of extradition proceedings, a warrant of arrest must be issued by a court of law in the foreign country, only then will the person be deemed to be wanted for trial and, therefore, extraditable. In the unreported case of Attorney-General of the Federation v. Lawal Olaniyi Babafemi – Suit No. FHC/ABJ/CR/132/2013 – the Respondent was wanted for conspiracy to provide support to a Foreign Terrorist Organisation in the United States.
It was enough to show to the Federal High Court that there was a subsisting indictment against the Respondent as well as a warrant issued by a United States Magistrate Judge for the Respondent’s arrest. These qualified the Respondent as an extraditable person.
Notwithstanding, extradition proceedings are not intended to constitute the trial of a Respondent but is premised on a notion that it is in the interest of every state that persons fleeing from justice must be disallowed from seeking refuge outside the territory of the state where the person is wanted.
Lord Russell of Killowen, CJ noted in R v. Arton (No. 1) [1896] 1 Q.B. 108 that: “The law of extradition is without doubt founded upon the broad principle that it is to the interest of civilised communities that crimes acknowledged as such should not go unpunished and it is part of the comity of nations that one state should afford to another every assistance towards bringing persons guilty of such crimes to justice.”
Since the promulgation of the Extradition Act, Nigeria had received several requests for the extradition of fugitive criminals, one of the earliest being in 1976 when the Australian government made a request for the extradition of one John Rooseriley, a British national, from Nigeria. After due compliance with statutory requirements, order for the surrender of the fugitive was made by the then-Attorney General of the Federation and he was subsequently surrendered.
James Ibori, the former governor of Delta State, was extradited from the United Arab Emirates, in conjunction with the Federal Government of Nigeria, to the United Kingdom.
Procedural, operational and jurisdictional considerations in extradition: By the provision of the Extradition Act, only magistrates have jurisdiction in extradition matters.
However, the Extradition Act (Modification Order) 2014, promulgated pursuant to Section 315 of the 1999 Constitution, has now vested exclusive jurisdiction on extradition matters on the Federal High Court. This position was well taken in Orhiunu v. Attorney General of Federation (2005)1 NWLR (Pt. 906) 39 where the Court of Appeal held that the exclusive jurisdiction conferred on the Federal High Court by the Constitution cannot be limited otherwise than by the same Constitution.
Upon the receipt of an extradition request, the Attorney General of the Federation may either exercise his discretion to apply to the Federal High Court for the exercise of the Court’s extradition jurisdiction or refuse the request without giving any explanation for the refusal.
In George Udeozor v. the Federal Republic of Nigeria (2007) 15 NWLR (Pt. 1058) 499, the Court held that the Attorney-General of the Federation, and not the Court, is vested with the responsibility and powers to ascertain the conditionality for acceding to an extradition request. By the provisions of the Act, the Attorney-General, who is the Chief Legal Officer of the Federal Republic of Nigeria, has the discretion to exercise the power to initiate extradition proceedings.
While by sections 6(1) and (2) of the Extradition Act, it is the duty of the Attorney-General to receive the request for the surrender of a fugitive criminal in Nigeria, section 6(2) reposes the discretion in the Attorney-General to signify to the court that such a request has been made and he does that only after he satisfies himself on the basis of the information accompanying the request, that the provisions of section 3(a) to (i) are complied with. It will be noted, however, that nothing in the Act gives the court the powers to question the exercise of the discretion of the Attorney-General.
Notwithstanding, the question of whether the Attorney-General has complied with the provisions of section 3(a) to (i) of the Act is a question of fact which can be brought to the attention of the trial court only by affidavit evidence.
The applicable procedural rules in the Federal High Court in extradition matters is the Federal High Court (Extradition Proceedings) Rules 2014.
The application for extradition shall be in a format provided in the form contained in the Schedule to the Rules, and supported by:
1. Particulars of the fugitive whose extradition is requested;
2. A request for the surrender of the fugitive by the requesting state;
3. A duly authenticated warrant of arrest or certificate of conviction issued in the requesting State;
4.The particulars of the offence specified in the extradition request;
5.Particulars of the corresponding offence in Nigeria;
6.Supporting affidavits;
7.Written Address; and
8.Any other relevant document
The rules require that the application and supporting documents be served on the alleged fugitive offender who is at liberty to employ the services of legal practitioners. Thereafter, the Respondent may exercise his right to either consent to the extradition or file a counter affidavit in opposition to the extradition application, within five days of the receipt of the application, subject to such further extension as the Court may permit. In addition, the fugitive may file any other application within the time allowed for filing the counter affidavit.
In accordance with the provisions of section 17(1) of the Extradition Act, the Courts shall take judicial notice of the documents supplied by the representatives of the State making the extradition request, and such documents require no additional proof whether by means of oral evidence or otherwise.
While extradition proceedings are required to be public, the Extradition Proceeding Rules empowers the Court to impose reporting restrictions, withhold information from the public or order a hearing in private. As earlier noted, extradition proceedings, not being a trial of the alleged offender, does not require any arraignment.
Consequent upon the grant of an extradition order, the law requires that the fugitive shall not be surrendered until after the expiration of a period of 15 days from the date of the order.
As I noted last week, the existing extradition treaty between Nigeria and the United States of America came into force in 1935 when Nigeria was still a British Colony.
As stated by the United States Supreme Court in Valentine v. US 299 US. 5, 57 S.Ct. 100, extradition treaties between countries are executory in character, and the existing treaty with the United States of America is binding on the courts in Nigeria.
This therefore connotes that the courts will regard extradition treaties as being equivalent to local legislation, however subject to the provisions of the Extradition Act, 1966.
However, the determination of whether the offence for which a surrender is sought is sufficiently proved, or whether the offence comes within the statutory extraditable offences and the applicable treaty are matters to be left to the courts.
Conclusion: No doubt, DCP Abba Kyari has a pending criminal charge and a warrant of arrest issued against him by a court in the United States of America.
However, the exercise of the discretion of the Attorney General of the Federation in accordance with the provisions of the Extradition Act, upon the receipt of a request by the US government, will result in DCP Kyari’s extradition or not.
Crucially the office of the Attorney General of the Federation has stated that it is yet to receive a formal notification as required by the Act.
Much, therefore, remains to be seen in the coming weeks not only in the determination of an impending request for the extradition of DCP Kyari but even in the determination of bilateral relations between the Federal Republic of Nigeria and the United States of America. (Vanguard)

38 thoughts on “How and when Abba Kyari can be lawfully extradited to America to face trial, By Ade Babalola, SAN ”

  31. Tällä kyseisellä 30e ilmaista pelirahaa ilman talletusta -tarjouksella saadaan varmasti houkuteltua hyvä määrä lisää pelaajia nettikasinoille. 30e on jo suuri raha aloittelijalle ja hän voi täten jo tällä summalla päästä hyvin pelaamisen makuun. Pelaamisen aloittaminen on tehty todella helpoksi ja yksinkertaiseksi tämän tarjouksen avulla. Tämä avokätinen tarjous on turvallinen tapa aloittaa pelaaminen ja tutustua rauhassa nettikasinon käytäntöihin. Erittäin oiva tarjous pelaajille! https://zfk.gr/citinet/community/profile/nickolassteger3/ Vedonlyönti ilman rekisteröitymistä ei juurikaan sisällä heikkoja kohtia. Vedonlyönti ilman rekisteröitymistä on kuitenkin ominaisuus, joka on luotu helpottamaan ja nopeuttamaan vedonlyöntiä. Vedonlyönti ilman rekisteröitymistä toimii nykypäivänä lähes moitteetta ja osittain sen ansiosta vedonlyöntisivustot ilman rekisteröitymistä ovat ansainneet niin suuren suosion. Vedonlyönti ilman rekisteröitymistä on taas vastaava vedonlyöntiin, johon ei lyhyttä vakiintunutta termiä ole, vaikka jonkin verran käytetäänkin siitä termiä pikavedot. Toisinaan kuuluu myös käytettävän rekisteröintivapaa, joka on sinällään ihan oikein, mutta me emme sitä termiä ole käyttämässä tämän enempää. Vedonlyöntialustan (kohteet ja kertoimet) tuottaa SBTech, tuttu muun muassa Suomen Veikkauksen kumppanina.

    Reply

  32. Buccaneers -12.5 Opening point spread: Chargers -6Opening point total: 45.5Opening moneyline: Chargers -255, Broncos +250 In Sunday’s Buccaneers-Bears game, Tom Brady vs. Justin Fields will set a new NFL record for the largest age gap between starting quarterbacks.The previous record was Tom Brady vs. Mac Jones three weeks ago.Before that it was Tom Brady vs. Justin Herbert last year. The point spread for Sunday night’s Chicago Bears-Green Bay Packers game is one of the largest that the NFL North rivalry has seen in decades. The Buccaneers are a 3.5-point favorite in the game, according to Tipico Sportsbook. Opening point spread: Bears -3Opening point total: 44.5Opening moneyline: Bears -160, Lions +140 Even with the 49ers still to play, I think they are still the pick here. The Bears are 3-4 and while quarterback Justin Fields is the future, the emphasis is apparently on the future. With star running back David Montgomery sidelined, the Bears offense is off-track and just doesn’t look like themselves. The 49ers should roll here. https://trinationtri.com/community/profile/olgamcilrath272/ While most Indian betting sites now have live betting platforms, the quality of the live betting features can differ quite a bit. With unique offerings like multi-live betting, virtual representations of live matches, as well as live streaming, live betting has become more exciting than ever! That’s why we recommend picking one of the best live betting sites in India. Betway Online Sportsbook and Casino is a significant website as well as mobile app in both the Android and iOS versions for you to get lost in that holistic sports betting and gambling extravaganza. With legal certificates from the Malta Gaming Authority, Gambling Commission, Be Gamble Aware.org, International Betting Integrity Association, IBAS and e-Cogra amongst others, Betway sportsbook gives you more than enough place to join the family, wager and win some great bucks while rooting for your home team or star player. So, without worrying or waiting a step further, just click open the Betway sports betting website and Register or Sign Up from the top right panel by navigating through the user-friendly website.

    Reply

  33. North Orange County Homes with Large Lots Under Construction-Est.Complete=April -The TACOMA- 4 bed, 3 bath. In the Lifestyle Triangle, you’ll find a Gourmet Bistro Kitchen-large island, tile backsplash, granite counters, soft close doors & drawers, & GE stainless appliances! Large master bedroom w ensuite bath containing marble counters & 5′ marble shower w frameless glass doors. Other great features include: tankless water heater, irrigation system, covered back patio, & REAR-ENTRY GARAGE! *Model home open Tue-Sat 10a-5p* Photos are of similar home! If using GPS, enter “Sussex Drive Athens, AL” You will be automatically redirected to the requested page after 3 seconds.Don’t close this page. Please, wait for 3 seconds to pass to the page. If you are looking for a spacious home in the country with over 2 acres to enjoy beautiful Carolina sunsets, look no further. This home features a newly installed shower … https://www.goldenretrievers.es/foro/profile/rodstrack094019/ Please visit our International Site for listings outside the United States. Search 165 foreclosure for sale in New Jersey. View listing photos and nearby sales, and find the perfect foreclosure for sale in New Jersey. Search 165 foreclosure for sale in New Jersey. View listing photos and nearby sales, and find the perfect foreclosure for sale in New Jersey. You stopped by just in time to see these new foreclosure for sale. Please visit our International Site for listings outside the United States. Search 165 foreclosure for sale in New Jersey. View listing photos and nearby sales, and find the perfect foreclosure for sale in New Jersey. You stopped by just in time to see these new foreclosure for sale. You stopped by just in time to see these new foreclosure for sale. Get quick and easy access to your home value, neighborhood activity and financial possibilites.

    Reply

  34. You should be able to export all contacts to a file on the website then upload them to iCloud. Upon hitting the save button mentioned in the previous step, your contacts will be automatically synced into the Google account. To complete the entire process, make sure to complete the procedures by hitting the “Save” button as soon as the process is finished. Step 3Click Information from the top panel, you will see the Contacts, Messages and Call History of your iPhone. Click Contacts icon, then you will find those options: New, Recover, Backup, Save and Delete. To extract your contacts out and then transfer to Gmail, please select Backup. Apple keeps your contacts within its standalone “Contacts” app. Both entities are siloed vaults for contacts, and it can be confusing when your contacts aren’t synced to the devices you use most often. If you deleted a contact in Google Contacts, it’s also smart to have all your contacts synced to another service and to backup your device often so you never lose any data. https://kampung-inggris-pare.com/community/profile/kieratompkins84/ Do keep in mind if you have syncing between Mac and Google Contacts enabled this will happen automatically and you won’t need to import manually like this. The second method is to transfer using Gmail but only the contacts which are linked with the Gmail account will transfer. The Gmail account has to be enabled on your iPhone beforehand to do this. Here is how you can transfer contacts from iPhone to Android using Gmail: Please note this feature doesn t currently sync your messages and music, but if you re going the Pixel route, Google includes a Quick Switch Adapter that can transfer over messages—including iMessages—as well as music. If you re not getting a Pixel, you ll have to sync music manually with Google Play, as well as everything else beside calendar, contacts, and photos.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

News You may have missed

Eminent Nigerian women challenge Tinubu on the board of the North West Development Commission

editor October 4, 2024 0

Danger looms as high school fees stop many Bauchi children from resumption

editor October 4, 2024 0

3 days after deadline, naira-for-crude deal yet to begin

editor October 4, 2024 0

Electronic transactions are introduced by the CBN in the foreign exchange market.

editor October 4, 2024 0

NLC President Ajaero challenges FG at the hunger protest: “Tell Nigerians how wanted Briton got into Nigeria.”

editor October 4, 2024 0